On the 10th Anniversary of the September 11th Attacks

By David A. Ring

It is hard to fathom that ten years have passed since those horrific moments on the morning of September 11, 2001.  In the space of a few hours, it seemed that our whole world had changed and that the United States of America would never be the same.  Our nation and the world were shocked and stunned; our pain and grief was beyond expression.

Suddenly thousands had perished.  More would follow due to the events in the aftermath.  Time has passed, but the pain of our losses and the memory of that day has not dulled.  The historic relevance of that terrorist act will never fade.

The perpetrators of these attacks took joy in their perceived victory.  They watched for us to fall apart.  They anticipated our capitulation to the demands of their cause.  They assumed oncoming social and economic turmoil.  They proceeded to plan more attacks on our nation.

What these people didn’t truly understand was the real American spirit.  They didn’t realize that we do not capitulate.  They didn’t comprehend that our beliefs are totally ingrained in our beings, that we, as people, believe in freedom and democracy as being not just words, but the essence of our philosophy.  They were foolish to challenge the resolve of the American people.

Ten years from that tragic morning, we can now reflect on ourselves as people and a nation.  We have taken realistic precautions, but we have not changed our ways, our lifestyles, or our beliefs.  Our system of democracy continues.  Our belief in justice for all has grown stronger, not only in our homeland, but for all who need our support.

We have actively sought out those who would force their twisted beliefs on others through terrorist acts and have foiled thousands of their plots.  There have not been any successful attacks on U.S. soil since 9/11 by these groups.  They confused our niceness for weakness, and they have, and will, continue to pay the price.  Their leader already has.

As we gather now on this solemn anniversary let us remember the innocent people lost on that day.  Let us remember those who have given their all since that day to guarantee the freedom of others.  Let us always keep them in our hearts and our minds.  Let us vow to ourselves that we will carry on the pursuit of righteousness in honor of their, and our, defense and support of freedom, justice, and liberty for all people.

FFAI

On June 15th like many others I nervously awaited the release of the Saville Inquiry, it would be hard to believe that the truth could somehow be once again be delayed or worse denied, but after so many years of waiting I was not going to take anything for granted.  At work I was lucky enough to be able to access the live BBC coverage online.  Just prior to 10:30 a.m. EST the BBC switched to the Guildhall in Derry City, television cameras panned the windows of the building and showed what seemed to be hands of family members of those lost in Bloody Sunday, pointing to the what looked like a document and signally thumbs up.  Was it possible that after almost waiting for 40 years the truth would be told?

Before those thoughts could sink in the cameras were now broadcasting from the English Parliament. What I heard next took even more time to sink in.  The new Conservative Prime Minister David Cameron had no sooner started his address to Parliament when he said, “The conclusions of this report are absolutely clear. There is no doubt. There is nothing equivocal. There are no ambiguities. What happened on Bloody Sunday was both unjustified and unjustifiable. It was wrong”. Regarding the actions of the British soldiers that day Cameron said “you do not defend the British Army by defending the indefensible”.

Cameron then spoke the words that the families of those murdered and injured had waited 38 years for: “What happened should never, ever have happened. The families of those who died should not have had to live with the pain and hurt of that day – and a lifetime of loss. Some members of our Armed Forces acted wrongly. The Government is ultimately responsible for the conduct of the Armed Forces. And for that, on behalf of the Government – and indeed our country – I am deeply sorry.  I would also like to acknowledge the grief of the families of those killed. They have pursued their long campaign over thirty-eight years with great patience. Nothing can bring back those that were killed but I hope, as one relative has put it, the truth coming out can set people free.”

When the speech ended and the BBC cameras switched back to the Guildhall, the next half hour of coverage was something that I will never forget. Tony Doherty whose father Patrick was murdered profoundly stated “When the state kills its citizens, it is in the interests of all that those responsible be held to account. It is not just Derry, or one section of the people, but democracy itself which needs to look out. The British people need to know, the Irish people need to know, the world now knows.”

The cameras showed the family members coming outside of the Guildhall on the steps and stage, I saw the people we have marched with for years in Derry and it was as if you could actually see the weight that was lifted off their shoulders. I saw John Kelly raise his fist in vindication and thought of what he had told me just a few months earlier in Washington DC.  Like so many parents who lost sons on Bloody Sunday John’s mother never recovered from the loss of her son Michael or stopped striving for his justice.  She passed away several years ago but on her death bed John told me that the family decided to tell her that Michael had been finally exonerated, they couldn’t let her die without some sort of justice.  On this day Mrs. Kelly, her son and all those that died and were injured finally got the justice they deserved.  Rest in peace Mrs. Kelly and to all the parents and family members who have passed away waiting for justice.

Later the cameras showed Jean Heagarty, whom I also had met in Washington, she approached the stage and very symbolically ripped a copy of the Widgery report in half; relegating it once and for all for as the lies and garbage that it was.

As the large screens that flanked the stage showed a picture of the murdered and injured a family member of each victim took the stage to read their loved ones name, cite from the Saville inquiry the true events surrounding their murder and very symbolically announce to the world their innocence.  Truth and vindication and it only took 38 years.  The emotions of that morning are something that I will never forget, it was as powerful a moment as I have ever experienced.  I am sure that so many in the AOH and LAOH felt the same way especially those that have made the trips to partake in the commemoration marches.

In the aftermath of June 15th I would speak to a friend who aptly said; if prior to the release of Saville if they had given us a blank piece of paper and asked us to write what we would think would be the best case scenario we could not have said it any better than Cameron did.

Near the end of his speech to Parliament Cameron said; “this report and the Inquiry itself demonstrate how a State should hold itself to account… and how we are determined at all times – no matter how difficult – to judge ourselves against the highest standards. Openness and frankness about the past – however painful – do not make us weaker, they make us stronger.”  He added that “neither will we hide from the truth that confronts us today.”

I commend the words, actions and straightforwardness of David Cameron on June 15th; it is extremely unfortunate that none of his predecessors had the courage or fortitude to admit the truth which they no doubt knew.  For Cameron’s words to be more than just sound bites in response overwhelming evidence it is critical that he understands that there remain hundreds of other victims who deserve the same vindication that the Bloody Sunday victims and families have just received.  The high standards that the state should hold itself to, the openness and frankness about the past no matter how painful are the standards by which the English government should approach its need to tell the true story of its involvement in the North.  The family of those that were killed in acts of collusion by state security, those killed by paramilitaries, or any unresolved death also deserve no less.

Mark Twain once said “If you tell the truth you don’t have to remember anything.” It will not take multimillion dollar inquiries to get the truth; it just requires the truth and a vehicle where the truth and not necessarily prosecution is the main objective.  If the Saville inquiry has taught us anything it is that the truth does not cost anything but when the truth is concealed and suppressed deliberately the quest to right that wrong will cost society something much more expensive than money.  Prime Minister Cameron we will judge your words on your future actions.